Thats not up for discussion.
Emily will be living with us; its simply not up for debate, said Henry, placing his spoon aside. He hadnt touched his supper at all, as though bracing himself for the weight of the conversation. Weve got the spare roomits just been redecorated. So, in a fortnight, my daughter will be moving in.
Have you forgotten anything? Charlotte asked, counting to ten in her head before speaking. For example, the fact that the room is meant for our *future* child? Our child. Dont you remember that? Or perhaps youve overlooked that Emily has a mothershe ought to be living with her!
I do remember talking about having a child together, Henry replied, frowning in disappointment. He had hoped Charlotte would quietly accept his wordno more discussion needed. But we can put that off for a couple of years. Youre still finishing your degreethis isnt the time for babies. Besides, Emily doesnt fancy the idea of siblings. As for her motherHenrys lips twisted into a sour smileIm going to get full custody. Its too risky for Emily to stay under that womans roof!
Risky? Charlottes eyebrows rose in disbelief. Shes twelvenot exactly a toddler. And whats so dangerous? That her mum wont let her wander about after ten? Or that she makes her do her homework under threat of losing her phone or the WiFi? If thats all, Julias a saint in my bookGod knows Id have grounded her ages ago!
You dont know anything, Henry said through gritted teeth. Emilys shown me bruises, let me read horrible messages full of threats! I wont let anyone ruin my daughters life!
Youre doing it right nowgiving in to her every whim.
Charlotte stood up gently from the table, leaving her soup untouched. Her appetite had slipped away, chased off by the sight of her husbands scowl. Everyone had warned herdont rush into marriage! Live together a bit, see if you can withstand the strain. But Charlotte, ever clever, was sure she knew best. She had to beat her friends to the punch.
Why did no one approve the hasty wedding? Three reasons: Henry was on his second marriage, fifteen years older, and had a nearly grown daughter who was spoiled rotten in his eyes. Any one of those things might have been minor, but lumped together? Nearly a catastrophe.
The first two didnt bother Charlotte much. On the contrary, she liked that her husband was older and experienced. She knew first-hand his divorce from Julia was amicable; no complaints from either side.
The third reason Emily. Wildly overindulged, headstrong, and unruly. Shed been raised mostly by her grandmother, since both parents had worked flat out to secure her future. Emily hadnt cared much about the divorce, confident her father would never abandon herremarriage be hanged. But when Julia remarried, Emily came undone.
Her new stepfather launched into discipline mode, and Julia, with a new job and more time at home, backed him up. Curfew! Homework! Tutors! Emily fell behind in nearly everything at school. The change infuriated her, a girl whod grown used to hours of TV and computer games. So much so, she began to make up storiesfrightening storiesto wind up her father.
Yes, Emily wanted to live with Henry, knowing hed be absent with work and shed be left largely to her own devices. She didnt care about Charlotte, who was, after all, only nine years older than herself.
All for the promise of freedom, Emily would stop at nothing.
***
Emilys arriving tonight. Please get her room ready, and do try not to upset hershes been through enough, Henry informed Charlotte, contemplating which tie went with his new suit. If Id ever thought Julia would turn into a tyrant with a new man He trailed off, shaking his head. No sense wishing time backwards.
So, you still havent changed your mind, then? Charlotte asked, disappointment souring her voice. You really mean to bring Emily here? Shed hopedeven nowthat things might fall through. And who, dare I ask, is meant to look after her? Youre home atwhat?eight oclock most nights.
Youll keep an eye on her, Henry replied, nonchalant. Shes not a toddler, she can manage on her own.
Ive got exams coming up, remember? Charlotte shot back. You said yourself I need to focus on my studies. She offered a chilly smile. If Emily cant be quiet and not disrupt me, shell have to learn how to do the dishes and mop the floorthose can be her contributions for the next two weeks, at the very least.
Shes not your servant
Nor am I, Charlotte interrupted as Henrys protest began. If she lives under this roof, she does her share. And youd better lay out the ground ruleswith her, not just with me.
***
Dad, how can you let her boss me about? I cant even see my friends because your precious wife dumped all the housework on me while she sits there, watching telly!
Charlotte, whod caught the conversation by chance while passing the hall, gave a lopsided smile. She knew betterEmily barely lifted a finger. The sky would sooner turn upside down.
Ill have a word with Charlotte, promise. But you need to try as well, Emily. I know its hard, but I honestly cant be around all the time. Work things out with Charlotte. Show her youre a good girl at heart.
Ill see what I can do Emily replied, sullen. She knew she wasnt going to get anywhere with her father tonight. Ohand did you really buy her a car?
Yes. Why?
Nothing. Not important, Emily pouted. You told *me* you couldnt afford to send me abroad for the holidays. I really wanted that.
You cant go aloneyoure twelve, for goodness sake! Well go as a family, come summer.
I dont *want* to go with everyone! You dont even care about me, do you? Emily sniffed, her voice cracking. Why did you take me from Mum, then? Your precious wife doesnt want me here, youre always too busy
Charlotte stopped listening. It was clear: Emily would always get her wayover the trip, and much more besides. The girl was cunning; she was trying to force out one more competitor for Daddys cash, and likely shed succeed.
Charlotte was tired of Henrys criticisms. She made up her minda single row more, and shed file for divorce. And before she went, shed make sure to ruin any triumph Emily might feel, telling her that Henry would *still* part with a share of his earnings by lawthats just how alimony works.
***
Charlotte was rightdinner devolved into a barrage of complaints. Calmly, she listened, then declared she was filing for divorce.
I want peace, not endless accusations, thank you. And I did warn youindulging Emily was a mistake, she said, noticing Emilys victorious grin. And dont get too pleased with yourself, darlingno one knows how things will pan out. For example, I could give Henry an ultimatum: if he wants to see our childCharlotte stroked her stomach with a smilehe can only do so if you return to your mothers. Or something like that.
While Emily struggled for words and Henry tried to process, Charlotte took her already-packed case and walked out. In truth, she wasnt pregnant at allshe just wanted to rattle the smug little girl, and teach her husband a lesson about what he truly failed to understand of a childs mindAs the front door clicked shut, the sudden silence was heavier than any argument. Henry stared at the vacant space Charlotte had left behind, her words echoingchild, ultimatum. For the first time, he saw Emily not as a girl wronged, but as a storm that had swept through his life, toppling trust and possibility. Emilys grin faltered. She opened her mouth with some sharp retort, but none came. Instead, she slouched at the kitchen table, glancing furtively at her father.
What now? Emily said, voice small.
Henry didnt answer right away. He sank onto a chair, fingers massaging his temples, guilt creeping in as he recalled the look on Charlottes facea look hed dismissed one too many times. He thought, absurdly, of the untouched soup, cooling and congealing, and of what might have been if hed listened.
Across town, Charlotte paused outside in the quiet dusk, pressing a hand over her still-flat belly, uncertain if shed meant her parting words or uttered them out of hurt. But a strange peace settled in her chestthe future, unknown and unpromised, was finally hers to shape. She whispered a promise to the life she hoped would grow: Well choose better. Well be braver.
Back in the house, the spell of indulgence finally shattered. Henry looked at Emily, seeing now how lonely she looked, stripped of victory, just a child again. He reached for his phone, heart pounding, and dialed Julia. His voice trembled as he spoke: Maybe we need helpmaybe all of us do.
Outside, a breeze stirred the roses near the front step. The house, emptied of accusation, stood in fragile waitinga space where blame could finally give way to understanding. And somewhere in the new quiet, after the storm, a chance for something better was unfoldingmessy, uncertain, and real.












