The Forty-One Years Hidden in a Nebraska Hayloft

Nobody in Cairo, Nebraska ever asked Walter Dobbs where he was born. He fixed clocks, mended harnesses, painted delicate blue cornflowers on the cream-colored creamer sets Nell sold at the Grand Island farmers market every Saturday. People in a town of four hundred don't press a man about his past if he shows up, pays his tab at the feed store, and tips his hat at the Lutheran church on Sundays. For forty-one years, that was enough.

It started in the spring of 1944, out at Camp Atlanta, a prisoner-of-war compound thirty miles south where the Army held captured Wehrmacht soldiers and put them to work detasseling corn and hauling sugar beets for local farmers short on hands. Nell Hargrove, nineteen years old, had grown up two farms over from a Volga German family, the Kieslings, who'd taught her enough of the language to read a hymnal and curse at a stuck gate. The camp needed someone who could translate orders for the labor details, and Nell's name got passed along by the county extension agent.

That's where she met Private Erich Baumann. Before the war he'd apprenticed at the Nymphenburg porcelain works outside Munich, painting gold rims on teacups and dreaming of enrolling at the art academy. The Wehrmacht had other plans. He was captured outside Cherbourg in the summer of '44, shipped across the Atlantic on a troop transport, and landed in a cornfield in the middle of America wondering if he'd ever paint anything again.

He and Nell talked between work shifts. Then they started finding reasons to talk longer. By the time the war ended in Europe, something had taken root that neither of them had planned for and neither could walk away from.

The trouble came in early 1946, when the government began closing the camps and loading POWs onto trains and ships bound for repatriation. Most of the men welcomed it. Erich did not. His hometown sat inside the American zone, but the War Department's paperwork routed men by last recorded unit assignment, not hometown, and Erich's unit records had him pegged for transfer through the Soviet occupation zone in eastern Germany before release. Men who'd served on the Eastern Front were already coming back with stories of Soviet labor camps that swallowed Wehrmacht veterans for years. Erich didn't want to find out if those stories were true. He wanted to stay in Nebraska. He wanted to stay with Nell.

So three days before his transfer, he walked off the detail during a thunderstorm and didn't come back.

Nell hid him in the hayloft above her father's dairy barn. The elder Hargrove, a widower who'd lost a son at Anzio and had little patience left for the Army's paperwork anyway, looked the other way. For the first two years Erich barely came down in daylight. Every truck that rattled up the gravel road sent him flat against the rafters, breath held, listening for boots on the ladder. The county sheriff drove past twice a week on his regular route. A traveling Bible salesman once wandered into the barn looking for the outhouse and Erich spent four hours afterward convinced the man had seen his shadow through the loft slats.

Years did what years do. He learned to speak with a flat Nebraska vowel instead of a German one. He fixed the Hargroves' Singer sewing machine, then the neighbor's, then half the county's, charging a dollar fifty a visit. He designed the three-bedroom house he and Nell eventually built on the back forty, with a root cellar he dug two feet deeper than necessary, out of old habit.

His new name came from a dead relative. Nell had a cousin, Walter Dobbes, who'd died of scarlet fever as an infant in 1921 and whose birth certificate sat forgotten in a tin box at the county recorder's office in St. Paul. When Erich needed a Social Security card to work odd jobs without drawing questions, the clerk at the recorder's window misread the handwritten "Dobbes" on the old certificate and typed "Dobbs" instead. Nobody ever corrected it. Erich Baumann became Walter Dobbs on a piece of government paper, and that was that.

Their son, Daniel, was born in 1951. He grew up believing his father was a quiet farmhand from somewhere back East who didn't like to talk about his family. Walter taught him to paint a decent duck decoy and a passable landscape, skills Daniel never thought to question.

Daniel was thirty-nine years old, sitting at the kitchen table with a cup of coffee going cold in front of him, when his parents finally told him the truth. It was February 1987. Outside, the radio on the counter was playing a farm report out of Grand Island, something about soybean futures. Nell set down a plate of kolaches nobody touched and said, "Your father has something to tell you, and I want you to let him finish before you say anything."

Daniel didn't say anything for a long time after his father finished. Then he asked the only question that mattered to him: "Does this change who you are to me?"

Walter's hands, stained permanently gray along the knuckles from decades of clock grease, stayed flat on the table. "I don't know," he said. "I've been Walter longer than I was ever Erich."

Three weeks later, Erich Baumann walked into the Howard County Sheriff's office in St. Paul and asked to speak with someone from the federal government. The deputy on duty thought he was confused about a property dispute until Erich laid out, in plain and careful English, who he actually was.

An INS officer named Carl Mercer drove up from Omaha to take his statement. The investigation took four months: military records requests to the Bundesarchiv in Germany, a records check through the Army's old POW files, interviews with neighbors who'd known "Walter" for decades. No evidence turned up connecting him to any atrocity. He'd been a nineteen-year-old private who'd painted teacups before the war and run a hayloft existence after it. In June 1987, Mercer told the family there would be no deportation and no prosecution. Erich could apply for legal status under his real name if he chose.

He chose to keep both. Legal papers read Erich Walter Baumann-Dobbs. Everyone in Cairo kept calling him Walter anyway.

That fall, he flew to Munich for the first time since the war, carrying a passport with his real name in it for the first time in forty-one years. He stood in the church at Nymphenburg where a small bronze plaque listed the parish's war dead, his own name among them, carved in 1952 by a mother who'd buried an empty casket. He found two cousins still living in the city, both of whom had assumed for decades that the letters stopped because he'd died somewhere in a Soviet camp or a shallow French grave. He stayed three weeks, walked the porcelain workshop floor where he'd once painted cornflowers on teacups, and then he flew back to Nebraska.

He never went back to Germany again. He didn't need to. He died in Cairo in September 1994, seventy-four years old, with Nell beside him and a half-finished watch on the workbench in the next room.

The gravestone the funeral home ordered that week read WALTER DOBBS, 1920–1994, because that was still the name on his Social Security card and the only one most of the town had ever known. Nell let it stand for two years. Then, in 1996, she drove into Grand Island with Daniel and six hundred fifty dollars in cash and ordered a new granite marker from the monument shop on Second Street, this one engraved ERICH WALTER BAUMANN. She filed the correction with the county recorder herself, the old misspelled birth certificate finally retired to a folder marked CLOSED.

The old stone sits propped against the fence at the edge of the Cairo cemetery to this day, nobody quite willing to haul it to the dump. Walter Dobbs never existed. Erich Baumann is the name on the stone that matters now, and it's the one Nell reads out loud every Memorial Day, standing at the fence line with a coffee can of zinnias in her hand, telling whoever happens to be visiting the next plot over that the man buried there once painted teacups in Bavaria and spent forty-one years in a hayloft because he loved a girl from Howard County more than he feared getting caught.

Rate article
The Forty-One Years Hidden in a Nebraska Hayloft