Emma betrayed her husband just once, before the wedding. He called her fat and said she wouldnt fit into the bridal gown.
Even before marrying, Emma cheated on her fiancé only that one time. Stung by his cruel words, she went out with friends to a nightclub in London, drank too much, and woke in a strange flat beside a handsome blue-eyed man. The shame was unbearable! She never told Daniel, forgave his insults, and even started a diet. She quit drinkingeasy enough once she discovered she was pregnant.
Their daughter arrived right on time, a beautiful girl with blue eyes, and Daniel adored her. For five years, Emma told herself it was finethe girl had blue eyes because her grandfather did. And if her hair was curly, so what? Emma tried desperately to forget the man with tousled hair whose name shed erased. Yet in her mothers heart, she knewthis wasnt Daniels child. Maybe thats why she tolerated his late nights, his work trips, his endless nitpicking about her cooking and looks. For the girls sake, she endured. Where else would you go? her mother sighed. Your brothers moved his fiancée in, Grans bedriddentheres no room. I warned you not to put the house in your mother-in-laws name!
Emma held on. But it didnt matter. One day, Daniel left. Hed met someone else, he sobbed, promising hed always be Lilys fatherbut his heart had moved on. His mother, whod doted on the girl, hissed after the divorce: Get a paternity test. Why pay child support for nothing?
Emma froze. Shed thought she was alone in her doubts. Turns out, she wasnt.
Are you mad? Daniel snapped. Anyone can see Lilys mine!
Maybe his mother was right. A year later, appendicitis landed Emma in hospitalwhere she saw familiar blue eyes above a surgical mask.
Have we met? the doctor asked.
Emma shook her head violently, praying he wouldnt remember.
But he did. Next day, visiting, he teased: Hope you wont run off as fast as last time.
Emma flushed tomato-red. She planned to fleeyet by discharge, Thomas had her wanting to stay. She didnt mention Lily. Only that she had a daughter.
Thomas understood the moment he saw the girl. Nervous, he bought a doll, grilled Emma on how to act.
Listen, he said, my mum left my dad when I was small. My sister never accepted her new bloke, drove him off. I wont let that happen. Ill be Lilys second dad.
Emmas heart cracked. When he froze, staring at the girlthen at hershe knew: hed realised.
Whats the difference? she thought. Hed find out someday.
Bracing for shouts, she got a tearful hug instead: What a bloody miracle.
At first, Lily seemed fine with Thomas. But when Emma gently asked if he could move in, the girl wailed: I thought Dad was coming back! Let Thomas live elsewhere!
Emma soothed herbut Thomas was gutted.
Shes mine! They deserve the truth!
Daniel couldnt take it. Nor could Lily. To her, hes Dad. To him, shes his only childhis new wife cant have babies.
Thomas seethed. Lily threw tantrums. Emma juggled their fragile peace with rules: Daniel got visits (no meetups), Thomas was never left alone with Lily (theyd row), even Mothers Day cards were vetted to stop accidental truths.
Then Emma got pregnant againand panicked. What if this baby looked like Lily? What if Daniel guessed? What if Thomas spilled everything while she was in labour?
They planned for her mum to mind Lily. But Gallstones hospitalised Gran last-minute, her stepdad refused another kid, and her brother was working. Emma tried Danielaway on business. Leaving Lily with his mum? No chance.
Cant I look after my own daughter? Thomas fumed.
The birth was roughC-section, jaundice, extra hospital days. At home, tension hummed. Thomas claimed all was fine, but Lily clammed up. He told her, Emma feared.
Neighbours urged honesty: The truth always outs. Pay your dues. So she called Daniel:
I need to confess.
Confess what?
Long silence.
About Lily
What about her?
Emmas planned speech evaporated.
Shes your mates kid. Ive known forever.
He told you?
Figured it out ages back. Did my National Service medicalwas told Id never have kids. Kept quiet, hoped for a miracle. Then doubts. Mums too. Got it confirmed.
But why?
Emma reeled.
What could I do? he said. Not the kids fault! Dont tell her! I played dad to keep her.
Discharge day felt surreal. Lily and Thomas acted oddexchanging glances, unusually quiet.
Howd you two manage? Emma asked once the baby slept and Lily sketched.
Brilliant! You always interfered. We sorted ourselves.
Did you tell her?
Course not! You forbade it.
Then whys she so off?
Thomas smirked. Ask her.
Emma peeked into Lilys room. Tongue poking out, the girl coloured fiercely. The drawing: three adults, two kids.
Whos this? Emma asked.
Cant you tell? You, Dad, Thomas, me, and baby Oliver.
Lovely.
Mum can someone have two dads?
Emmas throat tightened.
Sometimes, yes, she said carefully.
So can I call Thomas Dad too? Hes nice. We built a LEGO castle, saw fish. A funny grandad at the shop asked what my dad does. Wasnt sure if he meant Thomas, so I said doctor. Cool having a doctor dad. I asked Thomas, but wanted to check with you.
Emma hugged her, realising the trap shed built. Daniel had forgiven. Thomas would too. But if Lily ever learned the truth Time to choose: live in fear, or set them free?
Of course you can, Emma whispered. Hed love that. But dont tell Dad.












