“Out of my house!” the mother said.
“Out,” Jane said, calm and measured.
Emily smirked, leaning back in her chair, certain her mother was addressing her friend instead.
“Out of my house!” Jane turned to her daughter.
“Sarah, did you see the post?” Emily’s friend all but flew into the kitchen, coat still on. “Ellies had her baby! Seven pounds, twenty inches! Spitting image of her dad, that nose! Ive been to every shop in town buying baby clothes. Why the long face?”
“Congratulations, Jane. Im happy for you,” Sarah replied, standing to make the friend some tea. “Sit down, at least take your coat off.”
“Oh, I cant stop long,” Jane said, barely perching on the edge of a chair. “So much to do! Emilys such a star, did everything herself, worked so hard. Her husbands a real catchtheyve just got their mortgage, doing up the place. Im so proud of her, truly. I raised her right!”
Sarah silently placed a mug in front of her friend. Raised her right, she thought. If only Jane knew…
***
Exactly two years ago, Emily, Janes daughter, had turned up at Sarahs unannounced, eyes swollen from crying, hands shaking.
“Auntie Sarah, please, dont tell Mum, Im begging you! If she finds out, itll break her heart,” Emily sobbed, twisting a wet tissue in her fists.
“Emily, calm down. Tell me whats happened,” Sarah urged, suddenly terrified.
“I its at work,” Emily hiccupped. “Someones purse went missing, fifty thousand pounds.”
They have me on the CCTV, coming into the office when no one was around. I didnt take it, Auntie Sarah, I swear!
But they said either I pay back fifty thousand by tomorrow lunchtime or theyll go to the police.
They say a witness saw me hiding the purse. Its a set up, Auntie Sarah! But wholl believe me?
“Fifty thousand?” Sarah frowned. “Why not ask your dad?”
“I did!” Emilys sobs renewed. “He said its my own fault, not a penny will he give me if Im that much of a fool. Told me, Go to the police, let them teach you a lesson. Wouldnt even let me insideshouted at me through the door.”
Auntie Sarah, Ive got nobody else. Ive managed to save up twenty thousand. I need thirty more.
“And your mum? You wont tell her?”
“No! Mum would destroy me. She already thinks Im an embarrassment, and now theft… Shes a teacher, everyone knows her. Please, can I borrow thirty thousand? Ill pay you back, two or three thousand a week. Ive found a new job!”
Please, Auntie Sarah?
Sarahs heart twisted. Twenty years old, about to start her life, and now this shadow over her. Her father turned his back, and her mother would surely cut her down.
Who hasnt made mistakes, Sarah wondered.
Emily kept crying.
“Alright,” she said quietly. “I have the money, I was saving up for dental work but that can wait.”
Just promise me this is the last time. And I wont breathe a word to your mum, since it scares you so.
“Thank you! Thank you, Auntie Sarah, you saved my life!” Emily flung her arms around her.
The first week, Emily brought over two thousand pounds, bright-eyed, said it was sorted, police werent involved, and things were fine at her new job.
And then… she stopped replying altogether. A month. Two, three. Sarah saw her at Janes birthday, but Emily barely acknowledged hera cold “Hello,” and that was it.
Sarah didnt push. She thought:
Shes young, shes ashamed, shell come round.
She decided thirty thousand pounds wasnt worth jeopardising her decades-long friendship with Jane. She wrote it off. Forgot it.
***
“Are you even listening?” Jane waved a hand in front of Sarahs face. “What are you thinking about?”
“Oh, just my own bits,” Sarah shook her head, gathering herself.
“Listen,” Jane dropped her voice, “I ran into Olivia the other dayremember, from upstairs? She caught me shopping yesterday. Odd, she was. Started asking after Ellie, if shed paid her debts and all sorts. I had no idea what she meant. I told her Emily was earning her own way, completely independent. Olivia just smirked and left.”
Do you know, did Emily ever borrow from her?”
Sarah felt a tightness in her stomach.
“No idea, Jane. Maybe just something small.”
“Anyway, I must dash. Need to stop by the chemist.” Jane kissed Sarah on the cheek and breezed out.
That evening, Sarah couldnt take it any more. She found Olivias number and rang her.
“Hey, Liv, its Sarah. I heard you saw Jane today? About those debtswhat was that about?”
A heavy sigh followed.
“Oh, Sarah I thought youd know. Youre closest to them all.”
Two years ago, Emily turned up at mine. Red-eyed, sniffling. Said shed been accused of theft at work.
Apparently she needed thirty thousand, or it would be jail. Begged me not to say a word to Jane. She cried and pleaded.
Like a fool, I gave her the money. She swore shed pay it back within a month. Never heard from her again…
Sarah gripped the phone tighter.
“Thirty thousand?” she echoed. “Exactly thirty?”
“Yep. Said thats just what she was short. Eventually sent me five hundred after six months, then vanished. Then I heard, from Vera in No. 11, Emily had tried the exact same story on her.”
Vera gave her forty thousand.
And old Mrs Green, their old teacher? She rescued Emily from prison tooshe gave her fifty thousand.
“Wait” Sarah sat down heavily. “You mean she asked everyone for the same thing, same story?”
“Thats right,” Olivias voice grew hard. “She squeezed a tribute out of all Janes friends. Thirty or forty thousand each. Spun the same tale, pulled at the heartstrings. We all love Jane, didnt want to upset her.”
And with that money, seems she just had a nice time. Month later, photos of her in Spain on social media, living it up.
“I gave her thirty thousand, too,” Sarah murmured.
“There we are, then,” said Olivia. “Five, maybe six of us. Thats become a business, Sarah. Thats more than a mistakeits fraud. And Janes none the wiser. So proud of her daughterdoesnt know shes raising a thief!”
Sarah ended the call. Her ears rang. She wasnt upset about the moneyshed long since let it go.
It was the calculated coldness of it all, how a twenty-year-old had conned every adult woman around her, using their love for her mother.
***
Next day, Sarah made her way to Janes. She had no intention of starting a rowshe just wanted to look Emily in the eye.
Emily was back from the hospital, waiting out the end of their flats renovations at her mothers.
“Oh, Auntie Sarah!” Emily offered a strained smile as she answered the door. “Come in. Tea?”
Jane was fussing at the stove.
“Sit down, Sarah, why didnt you call?”
Sarah sat across from Emily at the kitchen table.
“Emily,” she said calmly. “Yesterday I saw Olivia. And Vera. And Mrs Green. We had quite the conversation last nighta kind of support group for baby birds with broken wings.”
Emily froze, face blanching, flicking a glance at her mothers back.
“Whats this about, Sarah?” Jane turned around.
“Emily knows,” Sarah held her gaze. “You remember, Em, that little incident two years ago? When you asked me for thirty thousand? And Olivia, thirty. Vera, forty. Mrs Green, fifty. We all saved you from prisoneach of us sure we were the only ones who knew your dark secret.”
Janes hand shook; boiling water hissed and spat as she missed the mug.
“Fifty thousand?” Jane set the kettle down, her voice cold. “Emily? What is she talking about? Did you borrow from my friends? Even Mrs Green?”
“Mum its not like that” Emily stammered. “I I paid almost all of it back”
“You paid nothing, Emily,” Sarah snapped. “You gave me two grand to save face, then disappeared. You took nearly two hundred thousand off us all, spinning a sob story. We stayed quiet out of pity for your mum.”
But last night I realised we should have pitied ourselves.
“Emily, look me in the eye,” Jane demanded, voice trembling. “You lied to my friends? You made up a story about theft, just to rob the people who come here for tea?”
“Mum, I needed money for a deposit!” Emily cried. “You never gave me anything! Dad wouldnt even lend me a fiver; I had to start my life somehow!”
Whats the problem? Theyve got spare, its not like I took their last penny!
Sarah felt sick. So that was it.
“Jane, Im sorry for dumping this on you now. I cant keep protecting her. She lied to us all!”
Jane supported herself on the table, shoulders shaking hard.
“Out,” she said, voice flat.
Emily smirked, sure the words werent aimed at her.
“Out of my house!” Jane turned, eyes fierce. “Pack your things and go to your husband. I dont want to see you here again!”
Emilys face drained of colour.
“Mum, Ive just had a baby! I cant be stressed!”
“Youve no mother, Emily. I was her mother, the girl I thought was honest. Youre a thief.”
Mrs Green dear God, she called me every day, never breathed a word… How am I supposed to face her now?
Emily grabbed her bag, flung a tea towel to the floor.
“Keep your bloody money, then!” she yelled. “Youre both bitter old crows! Go to hell!”
She stormed into the other room, grabbed the babys carrycot, and stormed out.
Jane slumped into a chair, hiding her face in her hands. Sarah burned with shame.
“Im so sorry, Jane”
“No, Sarah you dont owe me anything. I should apologise, for raising that. I really thought shed made it on her own. But thisdear God, what shame”
Sarah stroked her friends shaking arm as Jane broke down in tears.
***
A week later, Emilys husband, worn and pale, made his rounds to all the creditors, eyes on the floor, apologising. He promised to repay everyone.
And he didfifty thousand for Mrs Green Jane repaid herself.
Sarah doesnt feel guilty about what happened. After all, surely a cheat should be punished. Isnt that right?












