Injustice “Mum,” Alina repeated, “Why didn’t I get the whole million? Why just three hundred and thirty thousand… What’s with that amount?” She could hear the hairdryer buzzing at her mum’s. Vera switched it off and called back to Alina: “Yes, that’s right,” Vera, ever so resourceful when it came to someone else’s million, replied. “Three hundred and thirty.” But Alina was supposed to have received much more. “Three hundred and thirty? Mum, where’s the other six hundred and seventy thousand? I was expecting almost a million. It’s Dad’s money—you were supposed to transfer it after selling the flat.” “Oh Alina, don’t start on your accounting again,” her mother tutted, “I did everything properly, you know that.” “Properly? Pardon me, but how is that ‘proper’? The floor creaked indignantly underfoot. “I gave you power of attorney to sell my flat, the one I inherited from my father. I asked you to transfer the money. Where is it, exactly?” Relaxing, it turned out, had been a mistake. “And I did!” The hairdryer fired up again. “But I acted as a mother, a good mother. I shared it out amongst all the children. Equally. Your legal third is in your account.” What she was truly owed should have been hers. “You split my father’s legacy three ways? For me and for them?” Alina meant her stepbrothers. “Mum, that money was mine! My father’s! We have different fathers, in case you’ve forgotten.” “What difference does it make who the father is?” her mother replied, now styling her hair. “The money is for the family. They’re your brothers. I’m your mother. Did you want me to sit by, watching you enjoy all that money, while your brothers just looked on? No, it had to be fair! I equalised everyone’s chances.” She wished she could go back to the day she signed that power of attorney and give her younger self a good shake… “Equally? You split my million into three? Three hundred and thirty-three thousand each! Where’s the rest, Mum? And the flat sold for a bit more than that.” “Yes, there was a little over a million after deductions and taxes,” Vera answered. “I rounded it off. And the extra—I kept it for all the hassle. Would you have dealt with all that paperwork? No! I did everything while you worked.” “Lucky you didn’t wear yourself out!” “Don’t you dare talk to me that way!” her mum snapped. “Your father may have been your dad, but I’m your mum. I decide. And besides, you’re a grown girl, the oldest, you need less than they do. I divided it equally. The boys need to start families soon. You’re a girl—a lot less is expected of you.” “So I don’t need a family of my own, then? Should I starve just because I’m a girl and ‘less is expected’?” Alina snapped back sarcastically. “Transfer the rest of the money. Now.” “No.” Short and sharp. Full stop. Her mother knew Alina wouldn’t do anything about it. Sue her own mum over money? No one would understand, everyone would judge. Mum is still mum—and at least they still talked. A couple of weeks later, after she’d calmed down and sorted her finances, Alina saw the photos on social media. Ivan posed with his brand new blue Polo. Dima posted, “My new ride!” The brothers had bought themselves cheap cars. Well, so be it. Alina set her three hundred and thirty thousand aside and decided to wait. Patience, as her gran always said, is golden. More than a year passed. Alina worked, saved, planned. She’d moved on, but hadn’t forgotten. Mum acted as if nothing had happened—still called, still chatted away. But today her mother’s voice was oddly chilling. Alina tensed. “What’s happened, Mum?” “Granny—” her mum stammered “—Ivan and Dima’s gran… she died this morning.” Alina felt a strange, cinematic detachment. That granny was never her granny, never played any role in her life. For Alina, she was just “mum’s mother-in-law” or “the boys’ gran.” Of course, she felt sorry for the loss. “Oh… my condolences.” “Someone has to organise the funeral, the paperwork—I’m all alone. The boys… they don’t know what to do. Can you come? Can you help?” Not out of spite, Alina explained she couldn’t get leave from work—it simply wasn’t possible for her to drop everything and fly across the country for the funeral of someone she’d met maybe three times. “Mum, I’m at work. I actually can’t make it to the funeral of a person I barely knew,” Alina replied. They’d never invited her to granny’s. “Oh please!” her mum begged. “I really, really need help.” “I can’t come, but I’ll help with money. How much do you need? Tell me—I’ll send it straight away.” Her mother hesitated, but didn’t say no. Money was always welcome. “It’s not the same, of course… but fine. Can you add twenty thousand?” “Of course. And Mum—I’ll send a little more besides, so you’ve got something for the little things. Call it my contribution to her memory… to their gran’s memory.” “Thank you, darling. You always help.” Alina hung up, feeling a grim satisfaction. She’d bought herself the excuse: she hadn’t gone, but she’d helped. No one could reproach her now. Six months passed, and the funeral faded into the background. Dima and Ivan seemed to have new toys—maybe motorbikes or new phones. One quiet Tuesday, Alina decided it was time. Sitting in the staff canteen, prepping for another meeting, she phoned her mum. “Hi Mum! How are you?” “Alina! All good. Dima’s got a new job—better than the old one. Ivan’s fine too, met a girl.” “I’m glad,” Alina replied. “Mum, I wanted to ask about something…” “What about?” her mother sounded wary. “I presume the six months have passed since granny’s death. Have all the inheritance matters been settled?” This conversation was even harder than the one over the original three hundred and thirty thousand. “Alina, what are you getting at? Of course it’s settled.” “So—where’s my share of the inheritance?” “What inheritance?” Mum feigned innocence, but Alina could tell she was lying; it was obvious. “From granny.” “But she wasn’t your gran.” “And what difference does that make?” Alina led her mum to her own logic, “I’m your child, you said no child should be deprived. You split my million three ways—made everything fair, remember?” “Alina, this is different!” Vera protested. “Totally different!” “How exactly is it different? You said inheritance is family property, you decide, and all children must be supported equally.” “Oh, don’t compare the situations…” “How convenient!” Alina retorted, dripping with sarcasm. “When it was my million—my father’s inheritance—suddenly everything had to be split in the name of family unity. But when it comes to their granny’s flat, now the inheritance strictly follows bloodline?” “Stop twisting my words!” her mother huffed. “You can’t mean you want to claim your brothers’ inheritance? How am I meant to explain that to the boys?” “I just want you to acknowledge you abused my trust by taking a third of my money on the grounds of ‘one family, one inheritance’. I’d like to use the same logic now, since you’re so fond of it. You helped them sell the flat, didn’t you?” “The money’s already gone.” “Gone where? Cars? Decorating? Then I want in too. Where’s my share, Mum? You told me I had to make do with less because I’m a girl. I don’t agree.” Her mother was taking her time, obviously chewing over how to wriggle out of the trap she herself had set a year before. In their family, it had always been this way. For the boys, her stepdad was Dad: they got all the best, all the necessary. That granny couldn’t stand Alina—she was only the “outsider” girl, never really a granddaughter. And her mother had never stuck up for her. “What’s wrong with you, Alina?” At a loss, her mum resorted to indignation. “Why do you need the money? You’ve got a job, you’re young, you’re healthy. You don’t need as much. Dima and Ivan—well, they need to start thinking about homes. They’re men! It’s harder for them!” “So, to sum up: my father’s inheritance is family property, because we’re siblings. Their granny’s inheritance is personal, because they’re men and I’m only a girl expected to need less?” “Don’t be cheeky,” her mother snapped. “Where does all your greed come from?” Her mother would never admit she was wrong. To her, Alina was just a penny-pincher for daring to demand fairness. “Perhaps you’re not aware, but that power of attorney obliges you to transfer the full proceeds from the flat. And the statute of limitations hasn’t expired. Not to threaten you, but…” “Alina! You’re not threatening your own mother, are you?” her mother whispered nervously. “No, Mum. Just reminding you—I’m still entitled to claim my money. Think about it.” Within a month, the full owed amount landed in Alina’s account. And then, pointedly, she was blocked.

Injustice

“Mum,” I asked again, “why did I only receive three hundred and thirty thousand? Why not a million? What sort of sum is that”

I could hear the hairdryer humming in the other room. Mum turned it off and replied,

“Yes, that’s right,” Mumher name was Margarethad deftly taken charge of the money, “Three hundred and thirty.”

But I should have received a much larger sum.

“Three hundred and thirty? Mum, wheres the remaining six hundred and seventy? I was expecting nearly a million. It was Dads moneyyou were supposed to transfer the full amount after selling the house.”

“Oh, Clara, dont start with your numbers,” she sighed, “You know perfectly well, I handled everything fairly.”

“What do you mean, fairly?” The parquet floor beneath my feet creaked, as if it too shared my outrage. “I gave you power of attorney to sell MY housethe one I inherited from my father. I asked you to send me the money. Where is it? Wheres it gone?”

Ah, I realised Id been too hasty to trust.

“And I did send it!” Mums hairdryer roared back to life, “But as your mother, I did what good mothers do. I split the money evenly between the children. Youve received your rightful third.”

But it was all supposed to be mine. Rightfully.

“You mean you split Dads inheritance between me and them?” I meant my step-brothers, Jack and Thomas. “Mum, that was my money! My fathers! Ive a different father to them, in case you’ve forgotten.”

“What difference does it make, whose father it is?” Mum was now brushing her hair, arranging it in front of the mirror. “The money belongs to the family. Theyre your brothers, and Im your mother. Would you really have me sit by while you receive all that and your brothers go without? That wouldnt be right! I made things fair. Even share for everyone.”

If only I could go back to the day I signed that document and give myself a proper scolding for my foolishness

“Even? You split my million into three! Three hundred and thirty three thousand each! Wheres the rest? The house sold for a bit more than that, even.”

“Well, yes, it ended up being a little over a million pounds after fees and taxes,” Margaret replied offhandedly. “I rounded it down. The rest I kept for myselffor all my trouble. Would you really have coped with all that endless paperwork? No! I did it all for you, while you were busy at work.”

“As if it was such a burden for you.”

“Dont take that tone with me!” Mum snapped. “Your father was only your father, but Im your mother, so I get to decide how things are done. And besides, youre the eldestyou need less than the boys. Theyll have families to support before long, while as a girl, expectations are different.”

“What, and I dont need a family? Or am I just supposed to live on scraps because Im a girl and so apparently need less?” I asked, my tone cutting. “Transfer the rest, Mum. Now.”

“No.”

Short and resolute. Full stop.

She knew I wouldnt press it. Who takes their own mother to court over money? No one would understand, and theyd whisper behind my back. And she was still my mother, after all, and we still spoke, sometimes.

A few weeks later, Id managed to calm myself and get my finances under control. But then I saw the photos on Jacks social mediashowing off a shiny blue Polo. Thomas had posted a picture as well, captioned “My brand new ride!”

Theyd each treated themselves to a cheap new car. Well, so be it. I decided to set aside my three hundred and thirty thousand and bide my time. Patience is golden, as Gran used to say.

More than a year passed. I worked, saved, planned. The sting of it all faded, but I never truly forgot. Mum behaved as if nothing had happenedshe rang, chirped away about this and that, always so cheerful.

But then today, her voice took on a chilly note that set my teeth on edge.

My nerves hardened.

“What is it, Mum?”

“Your brothers gran Jack and Thomass gran she passed away this morning.”

It was strangeI felt like a character in some old film, distanced from it all. That grandmother had never had a place in my life. For me, she was just “Mums mother-in-law” or “the boys gran.” Still, one feels sorry for any loss.

“Oh. My condolences,” I offered.

“I have to manage the funeral arrangements, paperwork, everything by myself. The boys well, theyre at a loss. Can you come? I need help?”

But I couldn’t gonot out of spite, but because work simply wouldn’t let me go.

“Mum, I cant just take off work and fly down for the funeral of someone I met three times at most,” I explained.

Shed never taken me to visit that grandmother anyway.

“Oh, please!” Mum begged. “I really need you.”

“I cant come, but Ill help with money. How much is needed? Tell me and Ill transfer it over.”

For a moment Mum hesitated, but she knew as well as I didmoney wouldnt go amiss.

“Its not quite the same but all right. Could you spare twenty thousand?”

“Itll be done. And you know what,” I paused, realising this was my chance, “I’ll send you a little more, in addition, so youre not worried for the smaller things. Think of it as my way of showing some respect for their gran.”

“Thank you, Clara. You always come through.”

I hung up, feeling a wretched sense of satisfaction. I now had my excuse: I hadnt come down, but I had helped. No one could blame me now.

Six months went by. The funeral faded into distant memory. Jack and Thomas, by the looks of it, had acquired new toysmaybe motorbikes, maybe the latest phones.

One quiet Tuesday, I decided it was time. I dialled Mums number, sitting in the staff room at work as I prepared for the next meeting.

“Hello, Mum! How are things?”

“Clara! All ticking along. Thomas has a new jobbetter pay than the last one. Jack well, hes happy enough, seeing someone new.”

“Im glad to hear it,” I replied. “Mum, I did want to ask about one thing”

“What thing?” she asked, suddenly guarded.

“Its been half a year since their gran died. I take it theyve received their inheritance?”

This time the conversation was more difficult than even the row over the three hundred and thirty thousand.

“Clara, what are you getting at? Yes, theyve sorted it.”

“Good. So wheres my share?”

“What share?” Mum tried to feign confusion, but after all these years, I could tell when she was lying.

“From the estate.”

“But she wasnt your grandmother.”

“And what difference does that make?” I pressed, echoing her logic from before. “Im your childyou always said that no one should be left out. When it was my fathers money, you shared it between us, in the name of fairness.”

“Clara, this is completely different!” Mum fired back. “Totally different!”

“How so? You said inheritance was family propertyyou decide, as mother, and everyone should have the same support!”

“Dont twist things”

“Oh I see!” I replied, sarcasm prickling my words. “How convenient! When you split my million, my dads inheritance became family property and had to be shared. But now, suddenly, when it comes to their grandmothers flat, inheritance is strictly divided along bloodlines?”

“Dont get clever with your words!” Mum huffed, her voice bristling, “Are you really saying you expect a share of my mother-in-laws estate? How am I supposed to explain that to the boys?”

“Im saying that you took advantage of my trust to swipe a third of my money, justifying it with your favourite logic One mother, one family, so everythings shared. Well, Id like to apply that logic to this situation, since youre so fond of it. You helped them with the sale too, didnt you?”

“The moneys already been spent.”

“Spent on what? Cars? Home improvements? Well, Id like a share too. Wheres my money, Mum? You told me before that I should be content with less, because Im a girl. But Im not.”

For a moment, she went quiet, likely pondering how to untangle herself from the logic trap shed set up herself years before. Thats how things always went in our family. My stepfather was dad to the boys, so they deserved the bestalways, and I was on the outside. That gran couldnt stand mesome outsiders child, never truly a granddaughter. Mum never stood up for me.

“Clara, what sort of person are you?” Mum finally shot back, clearly lost for arguments. “Why do you even care about the money? Youve got a good job, your health, your independence. You dont need as much. Thomas and Jack need to think about homes. Theyre men! Its harder for them!”

“So your view is: my fathers inheritance is to be split equally, because were siblings, but their grans money is only for thembecause theyre men, and Im merely a girl, whom little is expected of?”

“Dont be cheeky,” Mum retorted. “Where does all this greed come from?”

Mum would never admit she was wrong. In her eyes, I was the miser for simply asking for fairness.

“You might have forgotten, but with that power of attorney, you were obliged to transfer to me the whole amount from the sale. And you know, the statute of limitations hasnt passed yet. Im not threatening, but”

“Clara! Are you threatening your own mother?” she whispered in alarm.

“No, Mum. But I can still claim my money if I wish. Just think about that.”

A month later, the full amount owed to me was discreetly transferred. And then, pointedly, I was blocked from their phones and lives.

Rate article
Injustice “Mum,” Alina repeated, “Why didn’t I get the whole million? Why just three hundred and thirty thousand… What’s with that amount?” She could hear the hairdryer buzzing at her mum’s. Vera switched it off and called back to Alina: “Yes, that’s right,” Vera, ever so resourceful when it came to someone else’s million, replied. “Three hundred and thirty.” But Alina was supposed to have received much more. “Three hundred and thirty? Mum, where’s the other six hundred and seventy thousand? I was expecting almost a million. It’s Dad’s money—you were supposed to transfer it after selling the flat.” “Oh Alina, don’t start on your accounting again,” her mother tutted, “I did everything properly, you know that.” “Properly? Pardon me, but how is that ‘proper’? The floor creaked indignantly underfoot. “I gave you power of attorney to sell my flat, the one I inherited from my father. I asked you to transfer the money. Where is it, exactly?” Relaxing, it turned out, had been a mistake. “And I did!” The hairdryer fired up again. “But I acted as a mother, a good mother. I shared it out amongst all the children. Equally. Your legal third is in your account.” What she was truly owed should have been hers. “You split my father’s legacy three ways? For me and for them?” Alina meant her stepbrothers. “Mum, that money was mine! My father’s! We have different fathers, in case you’ve forgotten.” “What difference does it make who the father is?” her mother replied, now styling her hair. “The money is for the family. They’re your brothers. I’m your mother. Did you want me to sit by, watching you enjoy all that money, while your brothers just looked on? No, it had to be fair! I equalised everyone’s chances.” She wished she could go back to the day she signed that power of attorney and give her younger self a good shake… “Equally? You split my million into three? Three hundred and thirty-three thousand each! Where’s the rest, Mum? And the flat sold for a bit more than that.” “Yes, there was a little over a million after deductions and taxes,” Vera answered. “I rounded it off. And the extra—I kept it for all the hassle. Would you have dealt with all that paperwork? No! I did everything while you worked.” “Lucky you didn’t wear yourself out!” “Don’t you dare talk to me that way!” her mum snapped. “Your father may have been your dad, but I’m your mum. I decide. And besides, you’re a grown girl, the oldest, you need less than they do. I divided it equally. The boys need to start families soon. You’re a girl—a lot less is expected of you.” “So I don’t need a family of my own, then? Should I starve just because I’m a girl and ‘less is expected’?” Alina snapped back sarcastically. “Transfer the rest of the money. Now.” “No.” Short and sharp. Full stop. Her mother knew Alina wouldn’t do anything about it. Sue her own mum over money? No one would understand, everyone would judge. Mum is still mum—and at least they still talked. A couple of weeks later, after she’d calmed down and sorted her finances, Alina saw the photos on social media. Ivan posed with his brand new blue Polo. Dima posted, “My new ride!” The brothers had bought themselves cheap cars. Well, so be it. Alina set her three hundred and thirty thousand aside and decided to wait. Patience, as her gran always said, is golden. More than a year passed. Alina worked, saved, planned. She’d moved on, but hadn’t forgotten. Mum acted as if nothing had happened—still called, still chatted away. But today her mother’s voice was oddly chilling. Alina tensed. “What’s happened, Mum?” “Granny—” her mum stammered “—Ivan and Dima’s gran… she died this morning.” Alina felt a strange, cinematic detachment. That granny was never her granny, never played any role in her life. For Alina, she was just “mum’s mother-in-law” or “the boys’ gran.” Of course, she felt sorry for the loss. “Oh… my condolences.” “Someone has to organise the funeral, the paperwork—I’m all alone. The boys… they don’t know what to do. Can you come? Can you help?” Not out of spite, Alina explained she couldn’t get leave from work—it simply wasn’t possible for her to drop everything and fly across the country for the funeral of someone she’d met maybe three times. “Mum, I’m at work. I actually can’t make it to the funeral of a person I barely knew,” Alina replied. They’d never invited her to granny’s. “Oh please!” her mum begged. “I really, really need help.” “I can’t come, but I’ll help with money. How much do you need? Tell me—I’ll send it straight away.” Her mother hesitated, but didn’t say no. Money was always welcome. “It’s not the same, of course… but fine. Can you add twenty thousand?” “Of course. And Mum—I’ll send a little more besides, so you’ve got something for the little things. Call it my contribution to her memory… to their gran’s memory.” “Thank you, darling. You always help.” Alina hung up, feeling a grim satisfaction. She’d bought herself the excuse: she hadn’t gone, but she’d helped. No one could reproach her now. Six months passed, and the funeral faded into the background. Dima and Ivan seemed to have new toys—maybe motorbikes or new phones. One quiet Tuesday, Alina decided it was time. Sitting in the staff canteen, prepping for another meeting, she phoned her mum. “Hi Mum! How are you?” “Alina! All good. Dima’s got a new job—better than the old one. Ivan’s fine too, met a girl.” “I’m glad,” Alina replied. “Mum, I wanted to ask about something…” “What about?” her mother sounded wary. “I presume the six months have passed since granny’s death. Have all the inheritance matters been settled?” This conversation was even harder than the one over the original three hundred and thirty thousand. “Alina, what are you getting at? Of course it’s settled.” “So—where’s my share of the inheritance?” “What inheritance?” Mum feigned innocence, but Alina could tell she was lying; it was obvious. “From granny.” “But she wasn’t your gran.” “And what difference does that make?” Alina led her mum to her own logic, “I’m your child, you said no child should be deprived. You split my million three ways—made everything fair, remember?” “Alina, this is different!” Vera protested. “Totally different!” “How exactly is it different? You said inheritance is family property, you decide, and all children must be supported equally.” “Oh, don’t compare the situations…” “How convenient!” Alina retorted, dripping with sarcasm. “When it was my million—my father’s inheritance—suddenly everything had to be split in the name of family unity. But when it comes to their granny’s flat, now the inheritance strictly follows bloodline?” “Stop twisting my words!” her mother huffed. “You can’t mean you want to claim your brothers’ inheritance? How am I meant to explain that to the boys?” “I just want you to acknowledge you abused my trust by taking a third of my money on the grounds of ‘one family, one inheritance’. I’d like to use the same logic now, since you’re so fond of it. You helped them sell the flat, didn’t you?” “The money’s already gone.” “Gone where? Cars? Decorating? Then I want in too. Where’s my share, Mum? You told me I had to make do with less because I’m a girl. I don’t agree.” Her mother was taking her time, obviously chewing over how to wriggle out of the trap she herself had set a year before. In their family, it had always been this way. For the boys, her stepdad was Dad: they got all the best, all the necessary. That granny couldn’t stand Alina—she was only the “outsider” girl, never really a granddaughter. And her mother had never stuck up for her. “What’s wrong with you, Alina?” At a loss, her mum resorted to indignation. “Why do you need the money? You’ve got a job, you’re young, you’re healthy. You don’t need as much. Dima and Ivan—well, they need to start thinking about homes. They’re men! It’s harder for them!” “So, to sum up: my father’s inheritance is family property, because we’re siblings. Their granny’s inheritance is personal, because they’re men and I’m only a girl expected to need less?” “Don’t be cheeky,” her mother snapped. “Where does all your greed come from?” Her mother would never admit she was wrong. To her, Alina was just a penny-pincher for daring to demand fairness. “Perhaps you’re not aware, but that power of attorney obliges you to transfer the full proceeds from the flat. And the statute of limitations hasn’t expired. Not to threaten you, but…” “Alina! You’re not threatening your own mother, are you?” her mother whispered nervously. “No, Mum. Just reminding you—I’m still entitled to claim my money. Think about it.” Within a month, the full owed amount landed in Alina’s account. And then, pointedly, she was blocked.