Get out of my flat! said Mother.
Out, Mother said, calm as anything.
Emily smirked and leaned back in her chairshe thought her mother was talking to her friend.
Out of my flat! Susan turned to her daughter.
Beth, did you see the post? The friend burst into the kitchen, still wrapped in her coat. Emmy had a baby! Seven pounds six ounces, and twenty inches.
A spitting image of her father, same turned-up nose. Ive been in and out of all the shops, bought little outfits for her. Why are you so down in the mouth?
Congratulations, Susan. Im happy for you, said Beth, rising to pour her friend some tea. Sit down, at least take your coat off.
Oh, I cant stay long, Susan perched on the edge of her seat. So much to do, so much to sort. Emilys done brilliantly, all on her own, got on with it herself.
Her husbands a real gem, theyve just bought a flat on mortgage, getting it done up now. Im so proud of my girl. Shows I raised her right!
Beth quietly set the cup in front of her friend. Right… raised her rightif only Susan knew…
***
It was exactly two years ago, EmilySusans daughterturned up at Aunt Beths, no phone call, eyes red and puffy, hands shaking.
Auntie Beth, please, just dont tell Mum. Im begging you! If she finds out, itll break her heart, Emily sobbed, twisting a wet tissue.
Emily, calm yourself. Tell me properlywhat happened? Beth had been truly frightened that day.
I… at work… Emily hiccuped. Someones money went missingfrom a colleagues bag. Five hundred pounds.
And cameras saw me going into the office when no one else was about. I swear I didnt take it, Auntie Beth! Honestly!
But they said: either I return five hundred tomorrow by lunch, or they go to the police.
Theyve even got a witness who claims they saw me hiding a purse.
Its a stitch up, Auntie Beth! But wholl believe me?
Five hundred? Beth frowned. Why didnt you go to your father?
I did! Emily was swept up in another round of sobbing. He said it was my own fault, he wouldnt give me a penny if I was so useless.
Said, Go to the police, let them teach you a lesson.
He wouldnt even let me inside; shouted through the door.
Aunt Beth, theres no one elseIve saved two hundred, but Im short three hundred.
What about Susan? Why not tell her? Shes your mother.
No! Mum would eat me alive. She always says Im her shame as it isand now a theft…
Shes a schoolteacher, everyone knows her.
Please, lend me the three hundred? I swear Ill pay back two, three dozen a week. Ive found another job already!
Please, Aunt Beth!
Beths heart ached for the girl. Twenty, just starting outand heres this stain already.
Her father refused, turned his back, her mother would probably tear her head off…
Who hasnt made mistakes in life? Beth had thought.
Emily was in bits.
All right, she said. Ive got it. Was putting it by for my teeth, but theyll have to wait.
Just promise me this is the last time. And I wont breathe a word to your mother, if youre that scared.
Thank you! Thank you, Aunt Beth! Youve saved my life! Emily threw her arms round Beths neck.
The first week, Emily did bring in two dozen pounds, all smiles, saying its sorted, no trouble with the police, jobs going well now.
And then… she just stopped replying to texts. A month, two, three. Beth saw her at Susans parties, but Emily behaved as if they were strangerscold hello and nothing more.
Beth didnt chase her. She thought:
Well, shes young, probably ashamed and avoiding me.
She decided three hundred pounds wasnt worth wrecking decades of friendship with Susan. She wrote off the debt and let it go.
***
Are you listening to me at all? Susan waved a hand before Beths face. Whatre you daydreaming about?
Oh, just my own bits and bobs, Beth shook her head.
Listen, Susan lowered her voice. I bumped into Francesyou remember, our old neighbour? She came up to me yesterday in the greengrocers. All a bit strange.
Started asking about Emmy, you know, how shes getting on, if shed cleared her debts. I couldnt make head nor tail of it.
Told her Emilys totally independent, earning her own way. Frances sort of smirked and walked off.
Do you know if Emmy ever borrowed from her?
Beth tensed inside.
No idea, Susan. Maybe just a trifling sum.
Right, Ill head off then. Need to pop into Boots, Susan rose, pecked Beth on the cheek, and flitted off.
That evening Beth caved. She found Frances number and dialled.
Fran, hi, its Beth. Listen, you saw Susan todaywhat debts were you talking about?
On the other end came a hefty sigh.
Oh, BethI half thought you must know. Youre closest to them, after all.
Two years back, Emily came rushing to me. Snot everywhere, eyes all red. Said shed been accused of theft at work.
Either she paid three hundred, or prison. Begged me not to tell her mother, crying her eyes out.
Like a fool, I gave her the money. She promised to return it within a month. Then, nothing… vanished
Beth gripped the phone.
Three hundred? Youre sure?
Yes. Said thats just what she was short. In the end, a fiver six months later, then nothing more.
And then I heard from Vera in number twelve that Emily came to her with the same story.
Vera lent her four hundred.
And Mrs Goldsmith, their old teacher, rescued Emily from prison too. She forked out five hundred.
Wait Beth sat heavily on the sofa. So you meanshe asked the same thing from all of you? With the same story?
Seems like it, Francess voice had gone hard. That girl played the lot of usall Susans friendsfor three, four hundred each.
She spun the theft story, played for sympathy. We didnt want to upset Susan, we all care for her.
Emilys probably spent it allshe posted holiday snaps from Spain just weeks later.
I gave her three hundred too, Beth said quietly.
There we are then, Frances huffed. So there must be five or six of us at least. Might as well be a business, Beth.
Thats not a young mistake, its outright fraud. Susans none the wiserwalks around proud as punch of her daughter. And the girls a common thief!
Beth hung up. Her head hummed. She didnt even mourn the moneyshed written it off long ago.
It was the sickening realisation: how calculated and heartless a twenty-year-old could be, stringing along grown women, taking advantage of their goodwill.
***
Next day Beth went to Susans. She didnt intend a scene, just wanted to look Emily in the eye.
Emily had just arrived from hospital with her newborn, and was holed up at her mothers while her own flat was being renovated.
Oh, Auntie Beth! Emily smiled tightly at seeing her mothers friend on the doorstep. Come in. Tea?
Susan bustled at the stove.
Sit down, Beth love. You couldve rung, you know.
Beth sat at the table, across from Emily.
Em, Ive just seen Frances. And Vera. And Mrs Goldsmith. We had a good long chat last night. Put together a little help for victims club, as it were.
A freezing pause hungand Emily blanched, shooting a quick glance at her mothers back.
Whats this about? Susan turned round.
Well, Emily knows what about, Beth kept her eyes on the girl. Remember that nasty business two years ago?
When you borrowed three hundred from me? And Frances, three hundred. Vera, four hundred. Mrs Goldsmith, five hundred.
All to save you from prison. Each of us thought she alone was entrusted with your secret.
The kettle slipped in Susans hand, boiling water hissing down the hob.
What five hundred?! Susan slowly put the kettle down. Emily? Are you borrowing from my friends? Even Mrs Goldsmith?!
Mum its notits not what you thinkI I paid nearly all of it back
You paid nothing, Emily, Beth cut in. You gave me two dozen to keep up appearances, and vanished.
You got nearly two grand off all of us on a made-up tale, and we kept quiet out of pity for your mother.
But last night I realised: it wasnt Susan we should pityit was us.
Emily, look at me. You tricked my friends out of money? You made up a theft story to fleece visitors to my home?
Mum, I needed the money for a new place! Emily shouted. Neither of you would help me! Dad wouldnt give me an extra penny, and I had to start my life!
So what? They have plentywasnt like I took their last!
Beths stomach twisted.
I see. Sorry Susan, for dropping this on you now, but I cant keep quiet any longer.
I wont be party to this behaviour. Shes treating us all for fools!
Susan was leaning on the table, shoulders trembling.
Out, she said, in that same calm tone.
Emily smirked, leaning back, certain her mother was talking to Beth.
Out of my flat! Susan turned to her daughter. Pack your bagsgo home to your husband. Youre not welcome here!
Emilys face drained of colour.
Mum, Ive just had a babyI cant be stressed!
Youve no mother, Emily. My daughter was honest. You are a thief.
Mrs Goldsmith… oh Lord, she called every day to check in, never breathed a word How can I face her now? How?
Emily snatched her bag, flung a tea towel to the floor.
Stuff your precious money! she yelled. Bitter old hags, the lot of you!
She rushed into the next room, grabbed the babys carrier and fled the flat.
Susan sat down and covered her face with her hands. Beth was overcome with shame.
Im so sorry, Susan
No, Beth… its me whos sorry. For raising such asuch a person. I truly believed shed made something of herself on her own. And now What disgrace
Beth patted her friends shoulder as Susan broke down and wept.
***
A week later, Emilys husband, pale and drawn, went round all the creditors, apologising, unable to meet anyones gaze. He promised to repay all the sums.
Soon, repayments beganSusan herself paid Mrs Goldsmith back the five hundred for her daughter.
Beth doesnt blame herself for what happened. After all, a liar must face the music. Isnt that right?












