“It’s All My Fault, Obviously! My Boyfriend’s Sister Is in Tears—She Never Imagined This Could Happen, and Now She Has No Clue What to Do, or How to Save Face My boyfriend’s sister got married a few years ago. After the wedding, it was decided the newlyweds would live with her mother-in-law. The husband’s family had a spacious three-bedroom flat with only one son. ‘I’ll keep one room, and the rest is yours!’ said the mother-in-law. ‘We’re all well-mannered people, so I’m sure we’ll get along just fine.’ ‘We can always move out!’ the husband assured his wife. ‘I see nothing wrong with giving life under the same roof as my mum a try. If we can’t get along, we can always get a flat of our own…’ And that’s what they did. As it turned out, life together wasn’t easy at all. Both mum-in-law and daughter-in-law tried, but things grew worse each day. Resentment built up, arguments became a daily occurrence. ‘You said we’d move out if we couldn’t get along!’ his wife sobbed. ‘Well, we’ve hardly tried!’ replied her husband with a patronising smile. ‘These are small things—no need to pack your bags over it.’ Exactly a year after the wedding, she became pregnant and gave birth to a healthy son. The arrival of her grandson coincided with her mother-in-law leaving her old job and struggling to find a new one, since most bosses don’t want to hire a woman nearing retirement. So mother-in-law and daughter-in-law found themselves spending nearly 24 hours a day together, unable to go anywhere, and the atmosphere at home just kept getting worse. The husband shrugged and listened to the complaints—he was now the family’s sole breadwinner. ‘Right now, we can’t leave mum on her own—she can’t pay the bills. I can’t abandon her, and I certainly can’t afford to pay both rent and support my mum. Once she finds a job, we’ll move out!’ But the young woman’s patience ran out. She packed up her belongings and her child’s and moved in with her own mother. As she left she told her husband she would never set foot in his mother’s house again. If he cared about his family, he would have to think of a solution. She was sure her beloved valued his family and would return immediately to get her back. But she was mistaken. It’s been more than three months since she moved back home, and her husband hasn’t lifted a finger to win her back. He’s still living with his mum and only talks to his wife and child by video call after work; at weekends, he visits them at his mother-in-law’s. Now, the man enjoys attention and care from two women, and his own mother has plenty of sympathy for the son abandoned by his angry wife, but takes no real responsibility for their child. The husband is on easy street—and the mother-in-law probably thinks life is grand! Meanwhile, the young wife is utterly miserable. She still loves her husband, even though she knows he’s in the wrong. ‘What did you expect when you left?’ asks her husband, ‘You can come back whenever you want.’ She probably isn’t planning to leave her mother or rent a flat, as she’s on maternity leave and just can’t afford it. Is this really the end for their family? Do you think there’s even the slightest chance for her to move back in with her mother-in-law—and come out of this with her dignity intact?”

No need to say it this is all my fault! Ellie, my mate Jacks sister, broke down in tears. I could never have imagined anything like this happening! And now Ive no idea what Im supposed to do next. I dont even know how to handle things without losing face.

A few years back, Ellie married a bloke named David.

After the wedding, it was decided the newlyweds would live with Davids mum. His parents had a roomy three-bedroom house in Manchester, and David was their only child.

Ill keep one bedroom for myself, and the rest is yours! said the mother-in-law. Were all civilised people, Im sure well all get along just fine.

If things ever get difficult, we can always move out, David told Ellie later. I see nothing wrong with giving living under the same roof as my mum a go. If it doesnt work, well just find a flat to rent.

Thats exactly what they tried. Turns out, living together wasnt so simple. Both Ellie and her mother-in-law put in an effort, but tensions just built up day by day. Bottled-up frustrations would erupt now and again, and soon arguments became a regular thing.

You said wed move out if it didnt work! Ellie cried.

Well, havent we been managing? his mum would say, dismissively. Its not worth packing your bags over a few squabbles.

Exactly a year after the wedding, Ellie became pregnant and gave birth to a healthy baby boy.

Her sons arrival happened just when Davids mum had left her old office job and hadnt found anything new yet, since most companies didnt want to hire someone so close to retirement. So Ellie and her mother-in-law were more or less cooped up together all day every day, with nowhere else to go. Unsurprisingly, the mood at home got worse and worse.

David would only shrug and listen to the complaints, since he was the only one earning a wage at that point.

We cant just leave my mum now shes got no money to get by on. I cant just dump her, and I cant afford to rent us a place and send her money, too. As soon as Mum sorts herself a job, well move out.

But Ellie was running out of patience. Eventually, she packed up her and her sons things and moved back in with her own mum in Liverpool. When she left, she told David she wouldnt step foot in his mums house again. If his family was important to him, hed have to come up with another solution.

Ellie was sure that, because David cared about them, hed find a way to sort things out and bring her back. But she was wrong.

Its been over three months since Ellie moved back to her mums, and David hasnt lifted a finger to get her to come home. He still lives with his mum, catching up with Ellie and their son over FaceTime after work and visiting them at her mums for the weekend.

David now enjoys attention and concern from two women at once. His mothers got plenty of sympathy for the son his furious wife left behind, and otherwise, he hasnt got any responsibilities towards the child. Talk about coming out on top. And his mum is probably loving life too shes hardly lost anything at all.

Meanwhile, Ellies still upset about it all. She really does love her husband, though she knows full well hes behaving badly.

What did you expect when you left? David would ask. You can always come back if you want.

Truth is, Ellies in no position to leave her mums or rent a flat. Shes still on maternity leave, so naturally, she hasnt got the money.

So, is this the end of the road for their family?

Do you reckon theres any chance Ellie could ever go back to her mother-in-laws house and come out of it all with her dignity still intact?

Rate article
“It’s All My Fault, Obviously! My Boyfriend’s Sister Is in Tears—She Never Imagined This Could Happen, and Now She Has No Clue What to Do, or How to Save Face My boyfriend’s sister got married a few years ago. After the wedding, it was decided the newlyweds would live with her mother-in-law. The husband’s family had a spacious three-bedroom flat with only one son. ‘I’ll keep one room, and the rest is yours!’ said the mother-in-law. ‘We’re all well-mannered people, so I’m sure we’ll get along just fine.’ ‘We can always move out!’ the husband assured his wife. ‘I see nothing wrong with giving life under the same roof as my mum a try. If we can’t get along, we can always get a flat of our own…’ And that’s what they did. As it turned out, life together wasn’t easy at all. Both mum-in-law and daughter-in-law tried, but things grew worse each day. Resentment built up, arguments became a daily occurrence. ‘You said we’d move out if we couldn’t get along!’ his wife sobbed. ‘Well, we’ve hardly tried!’ replied her husband with a patronising smile. ‘These are small things—no need to pack your bags over it.’ Exactly a year after the wedding, she became pregnant and gave birth to a healthy son. The arrival of her grandson coincided with her mother-in-law leaving her old job and struggling to find a new one, since most bosses don’t want to hire a woman nearing retirement. So mother-in-law and daughter-in-law found themselves spending nearly 24 hours a day together, unable to go anywhere, and the atmosphere at home just kept getting worse. The husband shrugged and listened to the complaints—he was now the family’s sole breadwinner. ‘Right now, we can’t leave mum on her own—she can’t pay the bills. I can’t abandon her, and I certainly can’t afford to pay both rent and support my mum. Once she finds a job, we’ll move out!’ But the young woman’s patience ran out. She packed up her belongings and her child’s and moved in with her own mother. As she left she told her husband she would never set foot in his mother’s house again. If he cared about his family, he would have to think of a solution. She was sure her beloved valued his family and would return immediately to get her back. But she was mistaken. It’s been more than three months since she moved back home, and her husband hasn’t lifted a finger to win her back. He’s still living with his mum and only talks to his wife and child by video call after work; at weekends, he visits them at his mother-in-law’s. Now, the man enjoys attention and care from two women, and his own mother has plenty of sympathy for the son abandoned by his angry wife, but takes no real responsibility for their child. The husband is on easy street—and the mother-in-law probably thinks life is grand! Meanwhile, the young wife is utterly miserable. She still loves her husband, even though she knows he’s in the wrong. ‘What did you expect when you left?’ asks her husband, ‘You can come back whenever you want.’ She probably isn’t planning to leave her mother or rent a flat, as she’s on maternity leave and just can’t afford it. Is this really the end for their family? Do you think there’s even the slightest chance for her to move back in with her mother-in-law—and come out of this with her dignity intact?”