Husband Refuses to Let Daughter Live in Inherited City Apartment, Sparking Family Dispute Over Fairness and Future Plans for Their Children

Author Walton MerrittReading 3 minViews 1

My husband inherited a small flat in the city centre from his aunt. It’s quite compact, but in a good location. We have three children: our eldest daughter, Emily, is nineteen and at university. Our eldest son, Oliver, is twelve, and our youngest, Harry, is five. The five of us live comfortably in a spacious three-bedroom flat, so the children all have plenty of room.

Recently, my husband and I disagreed over what to do with the inherited flat. I suggested that Emily could move in there, as she’s becoming independent and might even get married in the near future. My husband, however, thinks that would be completely unfair to our sons, and wants to sell the flat, splitting the money evenly between the three children. But I cant help feeling thats a poor plan, since the amount each child receives wouldnt be enough for them to buy anything substantial when their time comes.

If we go ahead and do as my husband wishes, the money will just sit untouched in their bank accounts until the boys are grown. By then, perhaps Emily could buy a second-hand car, but it seems a flat you can actually live in is far more useful. Im a firm believer in the saying, A bird in the hand is worth two in the bushat least one of our children would have a secure place to live, and when the boys are older, we could figure out how to help them with housing too.

My husband worries that giving the flat to Emily would create resentment between the siblings, leaving them with a sense of injustice that could damage their relationships. But I feel our children are still young enoughespecially the boysnot to be bothered by these decisions, which gives us time to plan for their futures.

Weve not said a word to Emily about any of this. We agreed to settle our thoughts first, as the inherited flat is in dire need of refurbishment and, as it stands, isnt habitable. We simply dont have the money for repairs right now.

Now, Im left wondering who is rightme or my husband? Should I stand my ground or see reason in his view? Or perhaps theres a wiser option that we havent noticed? Maybe sometimes the best way forward comes from a bit of patience and open-mindedness, remembering that every familys happiness depends more on understanding and fairness than on brick and mortar alone.

The Key in His Hand Rain tapped at the window of the flat in a ceaseless rhythm, like a metronome counting down to the end. Michael perched on the edge of his battered single bed, hunched as if he could shrink small enough to escape his own fate. His large hands, once strong and sure at the factory floor, now rested helplessly in his lap. Sometimes his fingers clenched, grasping for something intangible. He wasn’t just looking at the wall—he saw mapped out on the peeling wallpaper the hopeless routes from his local GP to the private diagnostic centre. His gaze had faded, like an old film stuck on a single scene. Another doctor, another knowing “Well, at your age, what do you expect?” He didn’t even feel angry anymore. Anger asks for strength, and he had none left. Only weariness remained. The pain in his back was more than a symptom—it was his landscape, the backdrop to every action and thought, the white noise of helplessness that drowned out everything else. He obeyed all the instructions: took the pills, rubbed in the balms, lay on the cold couch at the physio clinic, feeling like some disassembled machine abandoned on the scrapheap. And all the while—he waited. Passively, almost with religious patience, he waited for someone—some state service, brilliant doctor or clever professor—to finally throw him a lifeline before he slipped under for good. He watched the horizon of his life, but saw only the drizzling tapestry outside the window. Michael’s willpower, once the tool with which he solved every problem at work and at home, was now narrowed down to a single function: endure, and hope for a miracle laid at his door. Family… He had one, but it slipped away, quickly and definitively. It happened so fast. First his daughter, clever Katie, went off to London for a better life. He’d never opposed her decision—he’d always wanted more for her. “Dad, I’ll help you when I’m settled,” she’d said on the phone. But that wasn’t the point. Then his wife left—not to the corner shop, but for good. Rachel succumbed quickly—a ruthless cancer caught too late. Michael was left not only with a broken back, but a silent accusation: he, partly walking, partly bedridden, was still alive. But she, his anchor, his drive, his Ray, faded away in three months flat. He cared for her as best he could to the end. Until her cough grew raw and he saw that familiar, vanishing glint in her eyes. The last thing she said, in the hospital, clutching his hand: “Hang on, Mike…” He couldn’t. He broke, fully. Katie called, asked him to move into her rented flat, pleaded with him. But why would she need him there? In a stranger’s home. Besides, he wouldn’t burden her with his helplessness. And she wasn’t coming back. Now only Rachel’s younger sister, Val, visited—once a week, by the book. She brought soup in a tub, pasta or a couple of fishcakes, and a new box of painkillers. “How are you, Michael?” she’d ask, slipping off her coat. He’d nod, “Alright.” They’d sit in silence while Val tidied up his cramped flat—like tidying his things might somehow tidy his life. She’d leave behind her perfume and the faint, physical sense she’d performed a duty. He was grateful. And endlessly alone. His loneliness wasn’t just physical—it was a cell built from his own helplessness, grief, and strangled fury at an unfair world. One particularly bleak evening, his eyes ran over the worn carpet and landed on the key to his flat. He must have dropped it the last time he struggled in from the doctor’s. Just a key. Nothing special. A bit of metal. He stared as if seeing it for the first time—not a key, but something else. It just lay there. Quiet. Waiting. He thought of Granddad. Suddenly, brightly, as if someone had flicked on the light in a dark corner of memory. Granddad, Peter Evans, with an empty sleeve pinned to his belt, used to sit on a stool and tie his laces with one hand and a bent fork. Not rushing, but focused, giving a little victorious snort when he managed. “Watch this, Mikey,” Grandpa would say, eyes glowing with the triumph of wit over circumstance. “There’s always a tool nearby. Doesn’t always look like much—sometimes it’s rubbish. Trick is to spot your ally in the scrap.” Back then, Michael thought it was just old man’s talk, a fairytale for comfort. Granddad was a hero—heroes could do anything. But he, Michael, was just an ordinary man, and his war with back pain and loneliness left no room for heroic cutlery tricks. But looking at the key now, that old story wasn’t a comfort; it was a reproach. Grandpa never waited for rescue. He took what he had—a broken fork—and beat helplessness, if not pain or loss. What had Michael taken? Only passive, bitter waiting at the threshold of someone else’s charity. The thought unsettled him. The key—this bit of metal, echoing Granddad’s words—suddenly felt like a silent order. He stood up—first with a familiar groan, ashamed even in his empty flat. Shuffling two steps, he stretched out. Joints crunched like broken glass. He picked up the key. Tried to straighten—and the familiar white blast of pain sliced into his lower back. He froze, gritting his teeth, waiting for the wave to recede. But instead of collapsing back onto the bed, he moved, slow and careful, to the wall. Not thinking, not analysing, just following the impulse, he turned his back to the wall. Pressed the blunt end of the key against the wallpaper at the tenderest point. Then, gently, experimentally, leaned on it with his weight. No goal—to “stretch” or “massage”. This wasn’t medical. It was plain pressure. Force meeting force; pain meeting pain, reality colliding with reality. He found a spot where this struggle brought, not a new attack, but a strange dull relief—as if something inside just gave, loosened a millimetre. He shifted the key a little higher. Then low. Leaned in again. Repeated. Every movement slow, exploratory, listening for his body’s answer. Not treatment. Negotiation. The tool for these talks wasn’t a fancy stimulator, but the old door key. It was silly. The key wasn’t a cure. But the next evening, when pain returned, he tried it again. And again. Found spots where pressure brought not agony but a queer reprieve, as if he was prying apart the jaws from the inside. Then he started using the door frame for careful stretches. Noticed the glass of water on the bedside table—he ought to drink. Just water. Free. Michael stopped waiting with his hands folded. He used what he had: the key, the doorframe, the floor for the lightest stretches, his own determination. He started a notebook, not about pain, but “key victories”: “Today managed five more minutes standing at the hob.” He set up three empty baked bean tins on the windowsill, which he’d meant to bin. Filled them with earth from the front garden. Dropped a few small onions in each. Not a vegetable patch. But three tins of life, and his responsibility. A month later, at his appointment, the doctor flicked over the new scans and raised an eyebrow. “There’s been a change. Have you been doing exercises?” “Yes,” Michael said simply. “Making do with what I’ve got.” He didn’t mention the key. The doctor wouldn’t understand. But Michael did. Rescue hadn’t sailed in on a ship. It had been lying on the floor all along, while he’d stared at the wall and waited for someone else to turn on his light. One Wednesday, when Val arrived with the soup, she stopped short in the doorway. On the window, in the tinned cans, young onions were sprouting. The room smelled not of must and medicine, but something else—hopeful. “You… what’s this?” she managed, staring at him, sturdily standing by the sill. Michael, in the middle of gently watering his shoots with an old mug, turned. “An allotment,” he said simply. After a pause: “Want some for your soup? Homegrown, fresh.” She stayed longer that evening. They drank tea, and he, without mentioning aches, told her about the stairs in his block—how he climbed one flight a day now. Rescue didn’t come as Doctor Dolittle with a magic serum. It hid in a key, a doorframe, an empty tin and a plain set of stairs. It didn’t take away the pain, the loss, or his age. It just put tools in his hands—not to win the whole war, but to wage his own daily battles. And it turned out, if you stop waiting for a golden staircase from the sky and notice the ordinary, concrete one under your feet, just climbing a step at a time—slowly, with support—is life itself. And on the windowsill, in three tin cans, the brightest green onions in the world were growing. It was the finest garden imaginable.