Seventy-One and the Key She Never Gave Back

When my daughter took my car keys, she said she was doing it for my own safety. Three days later she called asking me to drive across town and bring her some paperwork.

My name is Donna Novak. I'm seventy-one years old, and I've lived in Slavic Village for forty-three years. I got my driver's license at twenty-four, back when the test still required you to parallel park a stick-shift Chevy without rolling into the curb. I drove my kids to preschool on Fleet Avenue, then later to Garfield Heights High School, and when my husband worked construction jobs in Columbus for weeks at a stretch, I was the one doing every grocery run, every pharmacy trip, everything. My Honda Civic — silver, bought in 2009 for fourteen thousand dollars — still sits in the driveway and still smells like the same vanilla air freshener it had ten years ago.

The trouble started in May, when I picked up my grandkids, Sophie and Anthony, from swim lessons at the Zone Recreation Center. I parked a little crooked because the sun was hitting the mirrors wrong. My daughter Kathy, when she came to get the kids, looked at the tires — one up on the curb, one on the grass — and didn't say anything. But that evening she called.

"Mom, maybe Ryan should start driving the kids. He's got flexible hours at work now."

"Did something happen?"

"No, no, it's just… traffic's gotten so much worse. You know what Broadway Avenue is like at rush hour now."

I didn't argue. I just told her I understood if that made her feel better. But something tightened in me, like I'd swallowed a stone that refused to go down any further than my throat.

For two weeks, nothing. My downstairs neighbor, Mrs. Helen, walked her mutt Rusty at exactly five o'clock every day, and every day she asked why I wasn't picking the grandkids up from the pool anymore. I had nothing to answer but a shrug.

Then Kathy called on a Wednesday, a little after five.

"Mom, I've got a problem. I need to pick up a package from the UPS Store on Mayfield Road before they close at six, and I'm stuck at work. Can you go?"

There was a pause on my end, longer than it needed to be.

"Drive there?"

"How else, Mom, it's clear across town."

"So traffic's different today than it was two weeks ago?"

Kathy got irritated, said I was mixing up two separate things that had nothing to do with each other. I didn't see it that way. Because if she'd decided I was unsafe behind the wheel with her kids in the car, she should've decided the same thing about me driving halfway across Cleveland on her own errand. She explained it herself, though I don't think she noticed:

"It's different when it's just you driving, versus when you've got the kids."

That sentence lit up in my head like a neon sign over an all-night pharmacy. It was never about safety. It was about the fact that the risk was fine with her as long as I was the only one in the car.

I never picked up the package. I told her that if the way I drove was a problem, it was a problem all the time, not only when it didn't suit her. She hung up without saying goodbye.

For a few days things stayed cold between us. Then my son-in-law Ryan brought it up at Sunday dinner at their place, while Kathy was in the kitchen getting the pie.

"Donna, don't take it too personal. Kathy saw an accident back in April, out on the Innerbelt curve downtown — some older guy lost control and hit a light pole. I think it shook her up pretty bad."

That explained something, but it didn't excuse everything. I told him Kathy should've told me that herself, not him, over pie.

So I proposed something concrete. I signed up for a senior driver refresher course through AAA, out on Rockside Road — not because I thought I couldn't drive, but because I wanted us talking about facts instead of feelings. I asked Kathy to come with me.

The instructor, a guy maybe in his thirties, ran me through an hour-long road test around the city — merging onto Broadway, parallel parking near Fleet Avenue, driving after dark. Afterward he sat down with us and said it straight: reaction time normal, eyesight normal, technique solid, just check my blind spot a beat earlier when merging onto the highway, and maybe avoid night driving when I'm tired. He didn't find a single reason I should stop driving.

Kathy sat next to me in that little office, eyes fixed on the printed results, and didn't say a word the whole ride home. I didn't ask her to hand back the job of driving the kids right away. That had to be her call.

Three weeks went by. She called on a Friday because Anthony had soccer practice over at the field on Harvard Avenue, and both she and Ryan were stuck — him on a work trip in Columbus, her dealing with some crisis at the office.

"Mom, can you get him there?"

"You sure?"

"Yeah."

I drove him. Since then I've gone back to picking up the grandkids sometimes, though Kathy's never actually said out loud that she was wrong. She just, one day, left a spare car seat for Anthony in the trunk of my Civic, no comment attached. It's still there.

I changed some things too. I avoid rush hour now when I can plan around it, and I have no trouble admitting that a few years from now, there might come a time to drive less. But I don't want anyone else deciding that time has already come just by looking at my birth date on a license.

In October I'm due for my license renewal — after seventy, Ohio makes you do it in person every four years instead of every eight. I've already made the appointment at the vision clinic on Broadway Avenue myself, no help from anyone. I'm bringing the folder with my certificate from the AAA refresher course along with me — just in case somebody else decides to make a call about me based on nothing but a birthdate.

Rate article
Seventy-One and the Key She Never Gave Back